Nibsy Favorites

Our crowd-pleasing, timeless staples. From the perfect chocolate chip to rich toffee crunches, these are the classic homemade bakes you'll crave every single day. Always baked fresh and made with simple ingredients.

3 products

  • Cream Crush Cookie A close-up of a cookies and cream cookie with chocolate cookie crumb filling, resting on a piece of brown paper against a light background.

    Cream Crush

    Cream Crush

    $4.50 USD
    $4.50 USD
  • The Classic Two half's chocolate chip cookies stacked on a wooden board, with one cookie leaning on top of the other to show the chewy cookie interior and chocolate chunks.

    The Classic

    The Classic

    $4.50 USD
    $4.50 USD
  • Toffee Crunch Cookie Two Half's of our Toffee chocolate chip cookies stacked on a light wooden board, with one cookie broken in half to show the chewy interior and chocolate chunks.

    Toffee Crunch

    Toffee Crunch

    $4.50 USD
    $4.50 USD